Core2Duoノートレビュー 's review (As Nature Made Him) 『I was in need of this book to do a synopsis and review on the subject matter for a sociology course in gender issues. The the college library has the book,but it wa always checked out or promised to someone else when it was returned. The waiting list went for about threee months.I really needed the book for the report, so I went to Amazon to get it. for about around six dollars I received the book within four days am very satisfied withe the service. the book is in good condition and well worth four stars.』
(An intruging look at a life ruined by medical quackery and the personalities behind this famous case) 『Whether your interest in this book is part of a social sciences or gender studies context, or you just want to read it for the sheer pleasure of reading, "As Nature Made Him" is captivating and entertaining. It is the story of a set of lives ruined by the quacky science and self-serving ego of one man, Dr. John Money, then-head of Johns Hopkins Psychohormonal Research Unit, a department Money founded and promulgated.
The chapters progress quickly and the book is filled with human drama and personalities. It is a quick read, helped by Colapinto's lucid prose and flowing journalistic writing style. It conveys warmth, depth, and intelligence and is a joy to read. Born as boy twins, Bruce suffered a circumcision accident that destroyed his penis. Following the advice of Money, his parents decided to raise him as Brenda, until age 14, when she made the decision to become a boy again. Taking the name David, a nod to the Biblical king who face seemingly insurmountable odds), he re-assumed the gender he always knew he was.
Chief among the good guys is Milton Diamond, the harried and tireless rival of Dr. Money who toiled for years in obscurity and pariahdom because of his opposition to the prominent nurturist theory of the time; and Dr. Mary McKenty, who helped Brenda/David towards healing.
Colapinto offers a rare and in-depth look into the lives of one family affected by his doctrinal obstinance. In the hands of a less skilled author, this sensitive and intensely painful experience may have not been handled as well. You will hate Dr Money as you read about his lack of medical scruples, self-serving deception, and unending arrogance. For 4 decades, he was the chief proponent and champion of the theory that gender identity was malleable and could be changed after birth. Boys with genital anomalies could be reassigned as girls, he insisted, and willfully deceived the scientific community for decades by reporting that the gender reassignment experiment was an unmitigated success.
Thankfully medical science has now swung in the favor of the naturist argument-- gender happens in the womb (hormonally determined by the presence or absence of testosterone in utero)-- and radical gender reassignment surgeries like those David suffered are now no longer being advocated.
Highly recommended for readers interest in true-life stories or topics of medical history and sociology/psychology or gender issues.』
(Not what I thought) 『Interesting, but not really what I expected. Story was more about the doctors than the individual. Book was obviously written before the person killed themselves.』
(A different point of view) 『Maybe I'm the only one that feels this way, but the thing that I focused on, and that I thought about most even long after reading the book, was how easily this "case", and others like it (no, Brenda/David is not the only person to suffer from a "botched" circumcision that led to a pediatric sex-change) could be avoided. Perhaps it's because I'm the parent of two young boys? Anyway, my point is that if we simply stop circumcising our sons, especially in cases where it's not medically or religiously "necessary", tragedies like this could so easily be avoided.』
(probably the best book I have read!) 『Wow!!! What a read, my friend Phil was raised as a girl for the first 25 years of his life and even after so many therpists, years of counselling&several operations to re-correct "himself" he still feels more comfortable keeping his long hair and still deliberates whether he can ever make that leap and have his breast implants removed. I am so glad I have found this book, now Phil my friend I truly have an insight into what life has dealt you. I only wish I could give this book 6 stars.』 『
In 1967, after a twin baby boy suffered a botched circumcision, his family agreed to a radical treatment that would alter his gender. The case would become one of the most famous in modern medicine -- and a total failure. As Nature Made Himtells the extraordinary story of David Reimer, who, when finally informed of his medical history, made the decision to live as a male. A macabre tale of medical arrogance, it is first and foremost a human drama of one man's -- and one family's -- amazing survival in the face of terrible odds.
』 『Once you begin readingAs Nature Made Him, a mesmerizing story of a medical tragedy and its traumatic results, you absolutely won't want to put it down. Following a botched circumcision, a family is convinced to raise their infant son, Bruce, as a girl. They rename the child Brenda and spend the next 14 years trying to transform him into a her. Brenda's childhood reads as one filled with anxiety and loneliness, and her fear and confusion are present on nearly every page concerning her early childhood. Much of her pain is caused by Dr. Money, who is presented as a villainous medical man attempting to coerce an unwilling child to submit to numerous unpleasant treatments.
Reading over interviews and reports of decisions made by this doctor, it's difficult to contain anger at the widespread results of his insistence that natural-born gender can be altered with little more than willpower and hormone treatments. The attempts of his parents, twin brother, and extended family to assist Brenda to be happily female are touching--the sense is overwhelmingly of a family wanting to do "right" while being terribly mislead as to what "right" is for her. As Brenda makes the decision to live life as a male (at age 14), she takes the name David and begins the process of reversing the effects of estrogen treatments. David's ultimately successful life--a solid marriage, honest and close family relationships, and his bravery in making his childhood public--bring an uplifting end to his story. Equally fascinating is the latest segment of the longtime nature/nurture controversy, and the interviews of various psychological researchers and practitioners form a larger framework around David's struggle to live as the gender he was meant to be.--Jill Lightner』
price:$2.19
African American Images
Usually ships in 24 hours Core2Duoノートレビュー 's review (redundant page after page) 『I read the entire book in 2 days which means it did not say much to make me think. It reads really easy because it says the same thing over and over, albeit with different words. In essence White culture is not appropriate for our Black youth and therefore our Black youth should not be subjected to being forced to learn White culture from ages 6 to 18 (1st grade - 12th grade).
One goal of the book is to empower Black people to take ownership of their heritage and responsiblity for educating their children with the appropriate lessons. It offered no suggestions to non-Black people about what they can do to include African culture in the classroom other than including a handful of African leaders and the traditional Black men in our lessons. The book shows fault with teaching the history of the US because it does not include a history of Africa simultaneously.
The last chapter, like many books designed to get people riled up to make a difference, offers suggestions on how Black people can unite their community and educate themselves. The book promotes segregation because White schools are not appropriate for our Black children. There should be Black schools run by Black people so that Black children can get an appropriate education. The author faults White people for teaching Black children with methods that exist in all power structures in the US. We are apparently oppressing our Black youth by teaching Black children skills that are used in all strata of influence.
I am interested in what the author has to say if/when Obama becomes President. What excuses will he have then for why Black children are not successful in our sterotypical White schools?』
(a quick read that needs to be read) 『First of all, as an educator of future educators of black boys, I loved the fact that this was a quick read. We have to be so careful of the labels we allow to be placed on children because they may accept them. Michael Porter is not afraid to expose what he has witnessed and offer practical solutions.If you are not afraid of truth, you have to read this eyeopener. Porter wrote that whether our boys become productive, prosperous, non criminalized men is a litmus test for public education.His experiences as a teacher of behavior disordered children made him answer no to the preceding question.』
(Excellent service) 『Service was quick and it arrived before the projected date. The book was in great condition-like new.』
(A Must Read For All Educators And Parents!) 『This book, along with Jawanzaa Kunjufu's books, is a must read for all educators. If you want to make a positive change in the lives of African American males, it is important to understand the "powers" that are in place that hinders the growth of not just our African American boys, but all of our children, because without the positive influences/gifts of these young boys, everyone will suffer.』
(TRUTH) 『As an educator, I can whole-heartedly agree! Thank you for putting this into print. PLease seek 60 Minute&20/20 for an audience. Give them the direction to investigate&and PLEASE follow through! I am buying this book&referring it to all of my co-workers. Ouch!』 『According to Michael Porter, some people believe that today's youth, especially African American males, are lost; many of them can be found inside Behavior Disorder classes in America's public school system. This book examines how African American males end up in dead end BD classes, what happens to them in these classes, and how people can help their community to get on a life enhancing path.』
price:$14.95
Kings Crossing Publishing
Usually ships in 24 hours Core2Duoノートレビュー 's review (GET THIS BOOK!) 『THIS BOOK WAS ON POINT! 4REAL. IF YOU'RE LOOKING 4 A GOOD BLK LESBIAN BOOK GET THIS BOOK RIGHT HERE! IM TELLING U THAT THIS BOOK IS THE BEST LESBIAN BOOK IVE READ IN A LONG TIME! IT TOOK ME 2 DAYS 2 FINISH!』
(Awful!!!) 『This book was really not what I expected from the summary. It sounded like a good story. Wow was I surprised. I was offended before I even finished the first page. I really tried to not make a snap judgement so I read a few more chapters. This was one of the most offensive books I have ever read. Are these characters supposed to be a realistic depiction of African American lesbians? I just can't believe that there are people as morally deficient as the ones described in this book. Just shocking! This really deserved a no star rating.』
(choices, shoices, choices) 『I must say i love, love love this book. while reading it i could really get into it. i felt like i was there with them. its a book you don't want to put down. i fell in love with denise, cooley, and nic. i must say skyy did the damn thang. thank you and hopefully there is more to come.』
(Good read!) 『This is a good book to read. Easy to follow and keeps your attention. Reading part two right now.』
(CANT WAIT TO READ CONSEQUENCES!!) 『I read the entire book the first day i recieved it..i couldnt stop reading it.. everyone can relate to some, if not all the problems in this book. At first i was wondering if it would hold my interest, and it did. Choices is a great book to read. And i cant wait until i read "consequences" the sequel to this book. The characters were so realistic and the way it was wrote it was like you right in the novel with them.』 『Set on the campus of Freedom University, a historically black college in Memphis, Tennessee, the lives and choices of four women are intertwined. Sexy and smart, Lena Jamerson has her whole life planned out for her. The daughter of two of Freedom s most prominent alums, it is a given that she will fulfill her Chi Theta Legacy as well as become engaged to NBA-bound Brandon Redding, or is it? With wealth, prestige and a beautiful body she could choose anything ... even someone new. Denise the reserved women's basketball champion has no time for dating. Her only choices are grades, game and becoming the first in her family to graduate, until a sexy stranger enters her life, causing her to reconsider her options. Playa of another flava, Cooley sparks curiosity of her own with women on both sides of the orientation fence. Will the choices of her past prevent the romance of her future? Meanwhile, Carmen's choices have given her a new exterior and a new lease on life. Can her sexy new shape get her into Chi Theta and a new romance? Or will the same internalized insecurities keep her from finding the love she deserves? In the school of life and love, what choices would you make?』
price:$12.50
Amber Quill Press, LLC
Usually ships in 24 hours 『(Gay / Erotic Romance / Contemporary) When Rowan Lee arrived in the small, liberal Provincetown, he heard tales of the eccentric, brilliant, possibly insane Finnegan Clark. A world-famous mystery writer, Finnegan's been to the top of the bestseller list more times than anyone can count. It's about the only place he goes, sequestered away in his mansion by the sea. Enter Rowan. The free-spirited lovechild of aging hippies, Rowan believes all anyone needs is love, and when he makes a delivery to Finn's mansion and meets the man himself, it's infatuation at first sight. Not to mention lust. Never mind that Finn's twice his age and snarls at him more than he speaks to him. All Rowan wants is to make the world a better place, one person at a time, but all Finn wants is to be left alone. Sparks fly, and if Rowan can't break Finn's walls down, he'll burn them down...one sizzling encounter at a time...』
Core2Duoノートレビュー 's review (The Briliance of Man) 『This book is amazing! it shows us that the human mind can be used for good or evil just like a gun or a car.
It shows us that we need to search for facts on these types of issues¬ listen to the hype of the ad men.
When we consider that Aids proper name is actually Grids "Gay Related Immune Diffiency", that in a study of white sodomite men by Gabriel Roto in his bok "Sexual Ecology" 75% of them had over 100 sexual partners&43% of them had over 500 sexual partners.
To actually promote&legitimize such a lifestyle is evil in the extreme. These people need counselling and every assistance they can get to leave this dangerous way of life. The last thing they need is encouragement.
Before any of you begin to shout that Gays can't help themselves they were born that way, consider what the authors of this very book say. They advise activists to claim they were born that way, "We argue that, for all practical purposes, gays should be considered to have been born gay," they write, "even though sexual orientation, for most humans, seems to be the product of a complex interaction between innate predispositions and environmental factors during childhod and early adolescence.
In a peer reviewed 1998 study "Sexual Abuse of Boys," by William C. Holmes, MD&Gail B. Slap MD, sexually abused males are 7 times more likely to be sodomites or sodomites who also have sex with women.
When a boy/teenager is sexualy molested and or doesn't have a good relationship with his dad it opens him up to all sorts of dangerous and strange practices.
In the "Marketing of Evil" David Kupelain explains that pushing the gay agenda is only the thin edge of the wedge and peodophilia, beastiality and all and every sexual perversion will be leagalised as long as the writers of this book and their associates can help it. By the way the Marketing of Evil is one of the best books I've ever read. 』
(Balanced and thoughtful and intelligent) 『A very good book on gays and what they can do to combat the bigotry they have to contend with. Some gays find this book offensive because it dares to suggest that marching for gay rights with your naked backside hanging out MIGHT cause some people to view gays as degenerates. I think the suggestion to march with dignity and purpose without resorting to shock tactics makes very good sense indeed. Reminds me of the old saying "you can catch more flies with honey than vinegar." Anyway, I enjoyed "After the Ball" very much and thought it very well written and researched and informative. A lot can be learned from this book.』
(Hitler would be pleased...) 『This is what happens when a group of people decide to get together and implement Hitlerian tactics to impose upon others their own demented views. Because they aren't accepted by society, they coerce society into acceptance through propaganistic tactics. At its core, this book is evil and twisted. When all is said and done people will probably hate gays more when the truth finally surfaces about this book and people begin to realize they've been manipulated and lied to. The homosexual movement is in its honeymoon right now enjoying its iron fisted approach to acceptance. But when all is said and done the homosexual fantasy will be exposed for what it is. 』
(Marshall Kirk) 『I would like to say thank you to everyone who purchased and got something out of "After the Ball." Marshall Kirk was my uncle. I say "was" because he passed away a year ago. I'm glad his legacy will live on in this book and all of the genealogy research he'd done over the years.』
(Prophetic book with a message for today) 『This book is a look at how gay activism can become more pragmatic and realistic. While "shock" tactics may be fun and a wonderful outlet for our pent up emotions (and may even have their place), this book shows why they are not effective at changing society or government. The first part of this book shows how to change society, using the same propaganda that is unfortunately being used against us by ignorant ministers and politicans whose lies and propaganda are absorbed faster than truth and reason by our society. The second half of the book explains how, despite the wonder and goodness of much of the gay community, some maladaptive behaviors have appeared in the gay community (primarily due to its persecution from less evolved members of our society) and how we can combat them to make our community even better and more nurturing. I don't agree with every conclusion the author makes, but it is a truly sobering message for gays and lesbians today; work with the system as it is or be second class citizens forever.』 『A compelling and compassionate work that never fails to stimulate. After the Ball is required reading for straights interested in understanding a minority that comprises 10% of the population and for gays who ar learning that the revolution is far from over.』
price:$4.20
Lethe Press
Usually ships in 24 hours Core2Duoノートレビュー 's review (Engaging, well-written mystery is third in great new series!) 『Twinkish, late 20's Castro waiter Tim Snow is trying to adapt to a long distance relationship with Nick Musgrove, who operates a big florist/garden center in the Russian River area north of San Francisco. Absence makes the heart grow fonder, but it also makes for occasional miscommunications, jealousy and frequent worries about each other. Tim's Aunt Ruth, who moved to San Francisco after visiting Tim here, is settling in as well, bartending at the same restaurant at which Tim works, and dating a successful older man. When the paper reports a possible murder near Nick's home, and Tim gets one of his vivid possibly-clairvoyant dreams that suggests Nick may be in danger, the couple reunite at Nick's cabin, not knowing that the killer could be watching their every move.
This third in Abramson's "Beach Reading" series continues to develop and provide background on these realistic, emotionally complete characters, while involving them in another outstanding, riveting and suspenseful mystery thriller. While I would recommend reading all of the books in order, for the full effect, each one can also stand alone as a great read. Abramson paints a wonderful picture of the diverse yet cohesive, supportive Castro community, and I can't wait until his next book to take me back to them. Bravo ... five warm sourdough stars out of five!
- Bob Lind, Echo Magazine 』
(Once More with Tim Snow) 『Abramson, Mark. "Russian River Rat: Beach Reading 3", Lethe Press, 2009.
Once More with Tim Snow
Amos Lassen
What a great character mark Abramson gives us in Tim Snow and it is good to have him back for a third time. Tim now thinks he has found the man to complement him--a handsome guy with his own business on the Russian River. Mark now has his Aunt Ruth with him, a wonderful partner and everything should be going well for him but....... Tim begins to have dreams that bother him and his boyfriend is showing signs that he is less than perfect and suddenly both men come into contact with men from their past who could cause trouble and even death. And that is all I am going to say about the plot so as not to spoil anything for any prospective reader. I will, however, mention that Abramson lured me in with his first book "Beach Reading" and cemented me in "Cold Serial Murder" so it was up to him to make sure that I would not be let down by "Russian River Rat" and I certainly feel he passed the test beautifully. Abramson is quite a writer. His characters are drawn beautifully and his plot here is carefully thought out. He pulls us in and does not let go even after we close the book. Not many can do that to me. 』 『Tim Snow is sure he's finally found the perfect man, a handsome guy with a successful greenhouse business by the Russian River. With his beloved Aunt Ruth now moved to San Francisco, his life should be worry-free. ButSan Francisco Chronicle's best-selling author Mark Abramson can't stop with telling lively mysteries--Tim starts having troubling dreams; a drowned body haunts his boyfriend, who may be less than perfect; and there are men from both their pasts who might be deadly.』
price:$4.19
Alyson Books
Usually ships in 24 hours Core2Duoノートレビュー 's review (Never received the book) 『I am very upset about the purchase. I purchased over a month ago and I never received the item. I tried contacting the seller for getting my refund but he never responded to my email.』
(spell all the way down to fight) 『It's a tender and precise written novel about finding out that it is not worth to find a place,to search for a place among all the narrow minded hoi polloi-section which is practically the consistence of every village, not only in the US. And how the great bars and cities and the waken nights help you to not only get along but fight for your desires which are not suggested by the police or state or church built up in the normal peoples heads.』
(Very hard to put down) 『I read this book in two sittings. The tone is conversational and the content is fascinating. The author really sucks you into the butch/femme culture, a world many of us don't know anything about. Incredibly emotive and perfectly accessible, I'm very glad I read this novel.』
(Trans Awareness) 『This is the first novel I read about a transgender character. It's extremely rich in its descriptions of the trans experience, as well as providing a much-needed historical perspective on this issue. So much of the book stayed with me after I read it, even when the prose wasn't necessarily the strongest. It didn't seem to matter. This is a powerful book.Verge』
(Stone Butch Blues) 『This book reads like a bad romance novel you would buy off of the shelf at the grocery store. There are WAY too many characters to keep up with and there really is no story line. The book is about Jess, a lesbian butch, trying to find her way through life...aren't we all? There really is nothing special about this book. It does offer SOME insight into how hard it must have been in the 1960's living as a homosexual, but the accounts are short and redundant. I feel like I am reading the same parts over and over again. Not worth reading.』 『
Published in 1993, this brave, original novel is considered to be the finest account ever written of the complexities of a transgendered existence.
Woman or man? That's the question that rages like a storm around Jess Goldberg, clouding her life and her identity. Growing up differently gendered in a blue--collar town in the 1950's, coming out as a butch in the bars and factories of the prefeminist '60s, deciding to pass as a man in order to survive when she is left without work or a community in the early '70s. This powerful, provocative and deeply moving novel sees Jess coming full circle, she learns to accept the complexities of being a transgendered person in a world demanding simple explanations: a he-she emerging whole, weathering the turbulence.
Leslie Feinberg is also the author ofTrans Liberation,Trans Gender WarriorsandTransgender Liberation, and is a noted activist and speaker on transgender issues.
price:$5.44
Crossing Press
Usually ships in 24 hours Core2Duoノートレビュー 's review (Zami: My New Favorite Book) 『This book is fabulous. It truly resonated with me and my experiences. Lorde writes beautifully! Read this.』
(Great!) 『It was in excellent condition and was shipped fast! I am very satisfied with this seller. I received this book within a few days.』
(What it was Like to be a Black Lesbian During the McCarthy Era) 『This memoir is of a black lesbian coming of age during the McCarthy era. Idealism, drugs, and trying to connect with others from the 'gay-girl' community are major themes. The book conveys the difficulty of being a minority - black, female and lesbian - and the impenetrable boundaries that are everywhere.
Audre Lorde also writes about her close relationships which appeared to be without substantive intimacy. Alcohol, drugs and mental illness often provided barriers to keep the sense of 'other' always in the forefront.
This is a fascinating book and an essential read for anyone interested in what it was like to be a minority during the McCarthy era.』
(Thank You) 『Amazon is a life saver. I needed this book in two days, after searching every barnes&noble and borders I could think of I went to amazon for help. There express one day shipping was a life saver. The shipping was costly but i learned my lesson for waiting until the last minute to get a book on my english syllabus. THANK YOU AMAZON for saving me in a crunch. I will diffently buy future books from your website =]』
(I love women) 『I had been putting off this book for about 4 years and I finally read it. I was putting it off because I read the first chapter and it was dry. I have to tell you that it gets better down the road. Audre is not just talking about lesbianism, she is talking about being a woman and general. You can get good relationship advice by NOT following what she did in her relationships. I was exposed to lesbianism of 20-30 years ago in this book. It's so different now and for women (of all sexualities and colors) this book is for you.
The only problem is that the beginning drags but once you are pass...let's say page 40 or the younger years you will be fine. Concerned, scared, hopeful...these are the things I felt for Audre. If you can't deal with the beginning put it down. However, I want you to know...one day I am sure you will pick it up again; or you should.』 『Lorde's self-named "biomythography"』
Core2Duoノートレビュー 's review (fantastic, but not for everyone) 『Jean Genet's seminal novel "Our Lady of the Flowers" is a glorious celebration of transvestites, lowlifes, prostitutes and murderers in the underworld of 1940s Paris. Our narrator, Jean, who may or may not be Genet himself, regales the reader from prison with stories he's created about fellow inmates between fits of furious masturbation.
The story begins with the death of Divine, a notorious drag queen and inmate of Jeans. From there Jean goes into the story of the recently canonized Divine, from "her" beginnings as the boy Culafroy to her living in an apartment overlooking the french cemetery Montmartre with her pimp Darling, and a young boy dubbed "Our Lady of the Flowers", whom recently committed a murder.
Our Lady is a brilliant exploration of the darker side of life. But naturally, a novel based around a perverted narrator inventing lives for people in order to help him masturbate isnt exactly for everyone. Id call it a healthy mix of Celine's stylistic sensibilities with Battaile's sexual overtones. An early influence on writers like Bukowski. And the 30 page, raving endorsement from Sartre in the preface should entice the existentialist crowd. So, give it a shot. You'll either be a little grossed out or particularly enthralled.
』
(Confusing tale of a gay man behind bars....I think) 『I figure to be the lone voice of dissent with this novel, which I found confusing and ultimately uninteresting. Genet's novel, written while in prison, jumps back and forth among the many characters, often following tangent upon tangent. I kept losing track of who was who, which one is supposed to be Genet (because I had the distinct impression that this novel might be autobiographical), sorting out the names and sequences of events, and trying to find a storyline that would last long enough to hold my interest. Genet would start on a good story and then all of a sudden jump in another reflection from that, never satisfactorily returning or finishing the original story.
It's very sexual and delves into the world of transvestism, but ultimately left me more confused than ever about what Genet was trying to say.』
(A Most Beautiful Song of the Imagination) 『Jean Genet is surely one of the greatest thinkers of the 20th century - not to mention one of the greatest dreamers. In this book he presents us with a web of characters that can only reach mythical preportions. And, interestingly enough, he reveals that the only reason for their creation is for his own pleasure. So the book becomes like a walk through Genet's subconcious, in which we meet different aspects of the total personality that is Jean Genet. The book is like a dream and throughout it we are confronted with monsters, saints, nuns, prison guards, and the most secret of desires. Genet is the only author I have read who is capable of opening himself so completely - and we do get the feeling that this is written for his own pleasure - this makes it all the more enjoyable for us to read!』
("Crime Begins With A Carelessly Worn Beret") 『Jean Genet's seminal Our Lady Of The Flowers (1943) is generally considered to be his finest fictional work. The first draft was written while Genet was incarcerated in a French prison; when the manuscript was discovered and destroyed by officials, Genet, still a prisoner, immediately set about writing it again. It isn't difficult to understand how and why Genet was able to reproduce the novel under such circumstances, because Our Lady Of The Flowers is nothing less than a mythic recreation of Genet's past and then - present history. Combining memories with facts, fantasies, speculations, irrational dreams, tender emotion, empathy, and philosophical insights, Genet probably made his isolation bearable by retreating into a world not only of his own making, but one over which he had total control.
The imprisoned narrator "Jean," who may or may not be identical with the author, masturbates regularly; like a perpetual motion machine, his fantasies fuel his writing and his writing spurs on his fantasies in turn. Nothing illustrates this more than the brief scene in which self - sustaining "Jean" describes his Tiamat.... Legs thrown over shoulders, "Jean" is not only the serpent that eats its tail but becomes a small, circular, self - imbibing universe all his own. A motto attributed to the alchemists could be the narrator's own: "Every man his own wife."
Though the narrative is not the primary focus of this or any of Genet's novels, most responsible critics have failed to remark on the fact that the narrative of Our Lady Of The Flowers is the least compelling of any found in his five major novels. Our Lady Of The Flowers, does, however, lay the basic groundwork for the novels to come: The Miracle Of The Rose, Funeral Rites, Querelle, and The Thief's Journal (all written between 1944 and 1948).
While Our Lady Of The Flowers is Genet's only novel to feature a predominantly effeminate homosexual man (Divine, who is at least partially a transvestite) as its protagonist ("Our Lady Of The Flowers," a virile young thug, is a secondary character), most of the other elements of the book will be very familiar to those who have read the balance of his fiction. Transvestites and transvestite figures abound, as do handsome, amoral, and homosexual or bisexual "toughs," jokes and extended vignettes concerned with lice, flatulence, constipation, and feces, mordant examinations of manhood and the criminal's code of honor, obsession with personal power through emotional betrayal, the long vagabond road to "sainthood," theft, masochistic love, prostitution, and vivid examples of the way in which physical desire and sexuality secretly and subtly fuel, in Genet's view, almost every aspect of life. As in portions of his other novels, the characters here, even the swaggering, virile young men, are known among their friends by fey pet names like "Darling Daintyfoot," "Mimosa," and "Our Lady of the Flowers," which are intended to be simultaneously affectionate and mocking. To further confuse, Divine is referred to as a "he" and referred to his surname during his youth and as a "she" and "Divine" in maturity. As in the Miracle of the Rose and Funeral Rites, characters mesh into one another, exchange identities, and move backward and forward through time at the narrator's whim. Both "Jean" and the individual characters fuse their own and each other's personalities together as needed, and all occasionally lose control of this process: but Jean Genet, master puppeteer, never does.
Genet's readers are probably aware of the existence of haughty establishment critics who pretentiously embrace Genet's work but nonetheless treat it like something best held at the end of a very long stick. "Evil" is the word most commonly used to describe Genet's fiction by stuffy, anxious middlebrow critics who, while distressingly stimulated by his work, feel duty - bound to officially decry its potential for pernicious influence. Many artists are said to create a "moral universe" within the body of their work; Genet is one of the few that actually does, though his is a mirror universe where amorality reigns. Genet's world is so exclusively concerned with flea - ridden prostitutes, child murderers who don't wipe themselves, handsome pimps who eat what they scratch out of their noses, [prostitutes] with rotting teeth, strutting, uneducated alpha male hustlers, and masochistic sodomites -- bourgeois emblems of horror all -- that the question of "evil" as such in Genet's work becomes obsolete.
While Genet loves and personally glorifies his memories, fictional recreations and their outcast lifestyles, he never objectively condones their actions to his audience. In all of his novels, Genet finds beauty, suffering, and vulnerability - humanity - in everyone, thus setting a far better example than his hypocritical reviewers. There is as much "evil" in Genet's books as there is represented by any typical novel's reality principle (for example, all of Genet's characters reveal more humanity and innate dignity than the crass, vacuous crowd Nick Carraway falls in with in Fitzgerald's The Great Gatsby) or, for that matter, as there is in the lives of those unstable, morally - confused critics who are simply too cowardly to recognize the world as the diverse, dangerous, devouring, and unstable place that it is. If Our Lady Of The Flowers proves anything, it's that fifty years after its initial publication, the book is still effectively upsetting the wormy apple carts Genet intended it to.
From the standpoint of Jung's psychological types, Genet's feeling and sensation functions probably predominated in both his life and his writing. However, his thinking and intuition functions were clearly constellated as well, giving Our Lady Of The Flowers and the masterpieces that followed it unmatched macrocosmic perceptiveness, poetic resonance, and gripping, all - inclusive dramatic power. Like alchemical "totality" the hermaphrodite, a shaman, or a legitimate Christian saint, mystic Genet seems to have written from a state of undifferentiated consciousness and enjoyed a state of perpetual participation mystique with life.』
(like a narcotic!) 『Somebody should make an opera of this book! I've loved this book since high school, perhaps more than all the others! Genet as always is like a dark narcotic; impossible to shake, and constantly ecstatic. His genius is like a kind of suffocating honey on the page, it pulls your heart out. This edition has a substantive Introduction by Sartre, whose "Saint Genet" is one of the seminal books of the late twentieth century. If you've never read Genet, you've got something coming! What is there to say about literature of this standing? Read it and be ennobled.』 『
Jean Genet's first, and arguably greatest, novel was written while he was in prison. As Sartre recounts in his introduction, Genet penned this work on the brown paper which inmates were supposed to use to fold bags as a form of occupational therapy. The masterpiece he managed to produce under those difficult conditions is a lyrical portrait of the criminal underground of Paris and the thieves, murderers and pimps who occupied it. Genet approached this world through his protagonist, Divine, a male transvestite prostitute. In the world of Our Lady of the Flowers, moral conventions are turned on their head. Sinners are portrayed as saints and when evil is not celebrated outright, it is at least viewed with a benign indifference. Whether one finds Genet's work shocking or thrilling, the novel remains almost as revolutionary today as when it was first published in 1943 in a limited edition, thanks to the help of one its earliest admirers, Jean Cocteau.
price:$7.34
University of California Press
Usually ships in 24 hours Core2Duoノートレビュー 's review (Looking at Classic Gay Texts) 『Sedgwick, Eva Kosofsky. "Epistemology of the Closet", University of California Press, 2008. (2nd edition).
Looking at Classic Gay Texts
Amos Lassen
Eva Kosofsky Sedgwick is one of the pioneering voices in the field of gay studies and queer theory. Her book, "Epistemology of the Closet" has been regarded as a classic since it first appeared in and now it has been re-released by the University of California Press. The book is a literary analysis of classic texts of American and European writers among whom are Herman Melville, Marcel Proust, Henry James and Oscar Wilde. Sedgwick's basic thesis is that there was a historical moment when sexual identification became an important sign of self as did gender. What she does with this thesis is analyze and examine literature by seeing how sexual preference shapes almost all aspects of modern contemporary thought. Sedgwick is provocative and her book is more than a literary analysis; it is also a study of culture and a political analysis. The book deals with the modern AIDS epidemic as well and shows how it influenced texts. Kosofsky writes beautifully and as the "mother" of queer theory she has a great deal to say. She maintains that gay men and lesbian women are represented in society and in literature as if homosexuality is deviant and perverse when compared to the larger society. Homosexuals have tended to remain closeted and it exists as a secret that wants to come out but dare not. This is a sensible argument and Sedgwick uses literature to bear this out. In doing so she looks at how it is that we came to our ideas about sexuality and why is it that we classify everyone as having either heterosexual or homosexual and ignoring any middle ground. She is an important thinker who cannot be ignored and whether we agree or not, we cannot deny that Sedgwick has something to say and it is important. She does show that the closet is impossibility because there is always someone who knows. It is easy to see how this book gained the status it has and it is good to have it back in print. 』
(The Closet Isn't Where It Ued To Be-) 『Most surveys of sexual variations seen in the historical context fail to take into account that sexuality has been defined and categorized differently in almost every era and culture. In western cultures, the current sexual categories became defined somewhere between the Civil War and world War I. In other words, there were no homosexuals (in the modern sense) before the Civil War. There were men who loved, and sometimes slept with, other men, but they didn't form a separate category. Social opprobrium was reserved for the practice of sodomy, whether it was practiced between men or men and women. Having sex with other men was simply something that wasn't discussed in public, although it happened all the time. Ms. Sedgwick has taken on the task of seeking to discover just how it is that we came by our current ideas of sexuality, why, for instance, that we seem to think that everyone is either heterosexual or homosexual, ignoring the reality that according to Kinsey, the vast majority are bisexually attracted, to at least some degree. She also examines the ways in which the public discussion of sexuality has changed and developed in the critical years between the two wars, using literature of the period for her sources. She contends, in my opinion successfully, that the gay/straight debate is the key issue for western culture, in terms of defining person-hood. Western culture has become obsessed with sex. It follows then, that issues of the conflict between the private and public spheres is central to her discussion. On the minus side, her prose is uneven, sometimes beautiful, sometimes turgid to the point of constipation. Her analyses are uneven, as well. I would have preferred a more thorough analysis of fewer examples, Billy Budd in particular. Taken on the whole, it's an important work by an important thinker who has added substantially to the discussion of sexuality and gender studies, well worth the effort required to read it with comprehension.』
(The "Problem" with Conceptual Schemes, New and Old) 『The August 11, 1999 "a reader" comments about Sedgwick's prose is especially valuable. The tendency to "abuse" language, in J. L. Austin's famous phrase, seems pronounced in Francophile and postmodernist writings, as if obscuritanism is a measure of profundity rather than a measure of obscuritanism. Several critics have justly claimed that unintelligibile writing and ideation only expose unintelligibility.
What could have been a provocative inquiry into the uniqueness of each human being (a novel, but now confirmed, fact, originating in Darwinian theory), once again reverts to a series of ideological templates to overlay the diversity of being and experience to "fit" a new paradigm. The dominant template here is the binary homosexual/heterosexual dichotomy, which Sedgwick insists is the prism by which we come to have knowledge of our world (I hope my effort at intelligibility does not misrepresent her views.)
Of course, the use of ideological templates laid over an inquiry is nothing new. Critical theory, Marxist theory, Freudian theory, and now Queer theory are variants of the same methodology. If one accepts the ideological template, then the subsequent examination under that template achieves a knowledge (i.e., epistemology) within the limits of that template, but generates a new conceptual scheme. Ironically, the ostensible purpose of the ideological template is to liberate thought from the status quo by forcing thought through an alternative sieve. The "insight" derived from this process becomes subversive of the status quo, but only to impose an different status quo that is putatively superior to the existent one.
According to psychology and anthropology, humans "by nature" impose categorical thinking on experience in order to "frame the reference" and "give order" to chaotic particularism of individual experience. This notion is no longer controversial, indeed, it is "obvious," with aetiology as far back to Hebraism and Hellenism, differing only in the templates used. So, instead of breaking the mold, the new theorists create new ones. Akin to Kuhn's paradigm shift applied outside science, we are prodded to look anew at the old phenomena.
But one of Darwin's keenest insights is the uniqueness of all living things, despite similarities. Instead of the essentialist thinking we inherited from Greek metaphysics and epistemology, we're told by Darwinians that we must use "population thinking," where "grouping" of things is by common descent, not our morphological, behavioral, or ideological similarities. I suggest this same motif applies to sexual populations, sexual expressions, and sexual orientation. Kinsey and others who have insisted on a continuum of orientation differences along a line between the polarities of opposites is truer to the truth than a "homosexual essence" or "heterosexual essence." The appellation of "gay" and "straight" are nominalist, not essentialist, groupings, where each appellation picks out a wide variety of differences by our conceptual schemes of categorization and understanding of populations, not by any essence. If true, and I believe it is, why revert to binary templates of essences to lay over the variety of differences as if one aspect, however shared, must then define many others as well?
Same-sex and opposite-sex relations are not as "neat and tidy" as theorists want us to believe, nor do they exist only in polarity, but rather along a continuum with yet another point between any other two points. Within different populations one finds vast varieties of sexual orientation and expression, not to mention vast differences in other facets of the human being, that homo- and hetero-sexual appellations conflate. To then use these conflated nominalisms as departure points (i.e., templates) for further inquiry only boxes in the subject further, thus undermining difference itself. Instead of nominalist pluralism one becomes both a reductionist and an essentialist to further categorize what is already tenuous at best. This paradigm shift in turn becomes its own raison d'etre further undermining uniqueness so that a new consensus of a new conceptual scheme can be forged.
Consequently, these projects have their own slippery slopes I'd prefer not to slide into. They all strike me as yet another "ideology" in the service of liberation, subverting one status quo for another, categorizing more categories, until we fit the new paradigm. I think we have had enough experience with this methodology to stop it before it starts.
Indeed, the courage to be authentic suggests the enterprise is not only subversive of the status quo, but subversive of our authenticity as well. Being unique, and therefore different, is both a starting and ending point, not a place to begin new essentialist programs to "fit" yet another putatively "new" conceptual scheme.』
(Deep wading) 『Ugh, a tough, tough book to read. I found myself really bogged down by this book and looked more forward just to getting through it than actually getting anything out of it. Sedgewick's style is definately not for me, but if you can get past the thick writing style you may be able to glean some interesting points from it.』
(...Theory should always be so good) 『According to the writer Avital Ronell, in his youth Kant wanted to be a poet. Fortunately for us, perhaps, he turned to philosophy instead. Through this turn Kant ended up setting the standard towards which most academics currently strive: a zero-degree style (which Lyotard both attempts to mime and identifies as naive in the preface to The Differend). What this does, essentially, is provide the rather stupid (and perpetually misrecognized) effect that an author is objective, sound, and important. Most of the time, authors are none of these.
People may disagree with me, but I find Sedgwick's style gorgeous and memorable. This may make the book difficult to read, but it also can make it quite a pleasure, and what else could one want from a well-informed, well-argued, politically necessary academic intervention?
For people deterred by Sedgwick's prose, I suggest you go pick up something more simple-minded. Whoever thought that reading a book shouldn't be a challenge? Who actually believes that one shouldn't struggle with difficult and new ideas?
The Epistemology of the Closet is a necessary book. Sedgwick's thoughts on ignorance and power (in response to Foucault's coupling of knowledge/power) are incredible. Her readings of Bowers v. Hardwick, the homosexual panic defense, and figurations of homosexuality are more than insightful: they are powerful critiques and exposes of the way that homophobia operates and is legitimated in contemporary American culture. Please please read this book. Read it twice or three times. Try it again and again. Each time you return, I promise you, you'll be startled by the ideas that come out, and hopefully, they'll mobilize you to do something more with them.
Take it to the next level and keep reading.』
『Since the late 1980s, queer studies and theory have become vital to the intellectual and political life of the United States. This has been due, in no small degree, to the influence of Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick's critically acclaimedEpistemology of the Closet.Working from classic texts of European and American writers--including Melville, James, Nietzsche, Proust, and Wilde--Sedgwick analyzes a turn-of-the-century historical moment in which sexual orientation became as important a demarcation of personhood as gender had been for centuries. In her preface to this updated edition Sedgwick places the book both personally and historically, looking specifically at the horror of the first wave of the AIDS epidemic and its influence on the text.』 『Since the late 1980s, queer studies and theory have become vital to the intellectual life of the U.S. This has been, to no small degree, due to the popularity of Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick's critically acclaimedEpistemology of the Closet. Working from classic texts of European and American writers--including Herman Melville, Henry James, Marcel Proust, and Oscar Wilde--Sedgwick delineates a historical moment in which sexual identity became as important a demarcation of personhood as gender had been for centuries.
Sedgwick's literary analysis, while provocative and often startling (you will never readBilly BuddorThe Picture of Dorian Graythe same way again), is simply the basis for a larger project of examining and analyzing how the categories of "homosexual" and "heterosexual" continue to shape almost all aspects of contemporary thought.Epistemology of the Closetis a sometimes-dense work, but one filled with wit and empathy. Sedgwick writes with great intelligence and an eye for irony, but always makes clear that her theories and critical acumen are in the service of a politic that seeks to make the world a better and more humane place for everyone. An extraordinary book that reshapes how we think about literature, sexuality, and everyday life.--Michael Bronski』